October 5, 2026

From returns to retirement outcomes: Rethinking what success looks like in pension funds

By Lisa Langner, FASSA – Head: Actuarial

For decades, retirement fund performance has been judged primarily on investment returns. Trustees and asset managers have focused on outperforming benchmarks and managing volatility. While these measures remain important, a profound global shift is underway: returns alone are no longer seen as sufficient.

Leading pension systems are increasingly defining success in terms of retirement outcomes, specifically whether members achieve a sustainable, an adequate and a predictable income in retirement. This reflects the reality of defined contribution systems, where members bear the risk and where poor decisions, poor timing or poor design can translate directly into financial insecurity.

As South Africa navigates the impact of reforms such as the two-pot system, there is an opportunity to rethink what retirement fund success should mean in practice. This shift aligns closely with King V, which emphasises long-term value creation, and demonstrating that value over time. In a retirement fund context, value cannot be defined solely by investment returns; it must ultimately be reflected in members’ financial security in retirement.

From performance reporting to outcome reporting

Traditional measures such as fund returns, peer rankings and volatility remain relevant, but they are increasingly recognised as incomplete indicators of success.

What ultimately matters is not how a portfolio performs in isolation, but the retirement income and standard of living it can support. As a result, many leading retirement systems are adopting more outcome-focused measures like projected retirement income, replacement ratios and assessments of retirement adequacy.

In practice, this means providing members and trustees with a clearer picture of what current savings may translate into at retirement. Income projections, scenario analysis and reporting that links accumulation to post-retirement outcomes are becoming increasingly important.

The implications for trustees are significant. Fiduciary duty is evolving from simply maximising returns to optimising member outcomes amidst uncertainty. This requires a broader understanding of risk that includes longevity, inflation and member behaviour; not just investment performance.

Decumulation: The missing link

Global attention is increasingly focused on what happens after retirement. While accumulation strategies have evolved considerably, the decumulation phase remains underdeveloped in many markets, including South Africa. This matters because retirement outcomes depend heavily on how savings are converted into income.

In response, several jurisdictions are introducing more structured retirement solutions. Jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom are moving towards default or guided retirement pathways that help individuals navigate complex choices, particularly where access to financial advice is limited.

Best practice is also moving beyond the traditional choice between life and living annuities. Increasingly, attention is focused on blended solutions that combine flexibility with protection against longevity risk. Flexible drawdown can support liquidity and member choice, while lifetime income components provide protection against outliving one’s savings. Research suggests that combining these objectives can improve retirement outcomes by balancing flexibility, sustainability and income security.

Globally, there is also renewed interest in risk-sharing mechanisms. Collective approaches, such as collective defined contribution (CDC) schemes and pooled longevity arrangements, allow members to share investment and longevity risks rather than managing them individually. In a CDC scheme, assets are pooled and managed collectively, with retirement outcomes reflecting the fund’s overall investment performance and longevity experience. While benefits are not guaranteed, risk-sharing across the membership can provide a more stable and sustainable retirement income than purely individual defined contribution arrangements, without creating additional liabilities for employers.

South Africa does not have a regulatory framework for CDC arrangements (where assets and risks are managed collectively across a membership pool), but elements of risk pooling already exist through products such as with-profit annuities. This is particularly relevant in a market dominated by living annuities that offer flexibility but also place considerable responsibility on retirees to manage investment, withdrawal and longevity risks.

A South African opportunity

This creates a practical opportunity for South African retirement funds. Default decumulation frameworks could provide members with structured pathways that guide them towards sustainable withdrawal strategies and appropriate asset allocation. Similarly, blended solutions that combine flexible drawdown with some form of lifetime income could materially improve retirement security.

These approaches align closely with the value creation principles embedded in King V. Retirement funds should consider whether their strategies, default arrangements and member communication are designed to help members achieve the outcome that matters most: lasting financial security in retirement.

This does not imply a one-size-fits-all solution. Members have different circumstances, resources and preferences. However, it does mean that funds should provide better guidance, better information and greater protection against predictable risks.

Designing for real behaviour

Even with improved product design, member behaviour remains a critical determinant of outcomes. Evidence consistently shows that people often make decisions that undermine their long-term financial security.

During the pre-retirement phase, members may save too little, fail to preserve benefits when changing jobs, make inappropriate investment choices or access retirement savings through the two-pot system to meet short-term financial needs.

The challenges continue after retirement. Living annuitants must decide how much income to draw, how to invest the remaining assets, and how to manage longevity risk.

Recognising these realities, leading retirement systems increasingly incorporate behavioural insights into their design. Simplified choices, default strategies, personalised projections and clearer communication help members make better decisions before retirement. After retirement, guided pathways and sustainable withdrawal strategies help retirees manage income more effectively.

Redefining success

Retirement systems are moving towards a more integrated definition of success. Investment performance, product design and member behaviour are no longer separate considerations, but part of a single objective: delivering sustainable retirement income.

For South Africa, the two-pot system, evolving governance expectations and the continued growth of defined contribution arrangements all point to the same conclusion. Retirement funds need to become more outcome-focused. Success should be measured not only by the returns a fund generates, but by the lasting financial security it helps members achieve.

Disclaimer

6 October 2026