IN PERSPECTIVE 4/2026
Pension Funds Adjudicator Cases
Pension Funds Adjudicator (Adjudicator) reaffirms trustees’ duty to verify dependency claims before allocating death benefits
AT Makgopa (Complainant) v BECSA Provident Fund (Fund) and ZA Zondo[1]
The case concerned the distribution of a death benefit following the death of a member of the BECSA Provident Fund.
The Fund identified four beneficiaries and allocated the benefit between the deceased’s mother, father, sister and an alleged girlfriend and cohabiting partner.
The deceased’s mother disputed the allocation to the cohabiting partner. The family maintained that the deceased did not have a cohabiting partner and requested proof that she was financially dependent on him.
The Fund stated that it had investigated in terms of section 37C of the Pension Funds Act (the Act) and relied on an affidavit from the cohabiting partner claiming that she lived with and was financially dependent on the deceased, as well as a supporting affidavit from the deceased’s landlord confirming this information.
Based on this information, the Fund concluded that the cohabiting partner qualified as a factual dependant and awarded her 10% of the death benefit.
During the Adjudicator’s investigation, the cohabiting partner made a shocking admission. She stated that she did not know the deceased, never been in a relationship with him, never lived with him and had been persuaded by a friend to sign a false affidavit in return for money. She also confirmed that she did not want any of the deceased’s death benefit.
The Adjudicator found that the Fund had failed to properly investigate the alleged dependency of the cohabiting partner. The trustees relied too heavily on affidavit evidence and did not take sufficient steps to verify whether the information was true.
As a result, the Adjudicator held that the board had not properly exercised its duties under section 37C of the Act and that its decision could not stand.
This matter is an important reminder that trustees must thoroughly investigate dependency claims before allocating death benefits under section 37C. Affidavits on their own are not enough. Funds must verify information and ensure that benefits are paid to the correct beneficiaries.
Withheld benefit following alleged CV fraud
KM Ramela (Complainant) v Alexander Forbes Retirement Fund (Fund) and Robben Island Museum (Employer)[2]
A former Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of the Robben Island Museum challenged the Fund’s decision to withhold his withdrawal benefit of approximately R389 534 after he was dismissed by his Employer for allegedly misrepresenting his professional qualifications. The Fund withheld the benefit at the employer’s request while criminal and recovery proceedings relating to the alleged fraud were being pursued.
The Employer alleged that the Complainant falsely represented himself as a member of the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) when he was appointed as CFO. According to the Employer, he occupied the position and received remuneration exceeding R4 million based on this alleged misrepresentation, resulting in substantial financial losses. This constituted fraud and corruption, as he knowingly received remuneration to which he was not entitled, while depriving legitimately qualified candidates of the opportunity to occupy the CFO position.
The Complainant argued that the withholding was unlawful because no criminal charges had been finalised and no civil judgment had yet been obtained against him. He maintained that his SAICA membership had merely lapsed due to non-payment of membership fees and that legal proceedings had not progressed sufficiently to justify withholding his benefit.
The Adjudicator found that the Employer had established a prima facie case showing that the Complainant caused damage as a result of dishonesty, supported by evidence from SAICA indicating that the complainant was not registered as a Chartered Accountant. The requirement of a prima facie cause of action is simply that an applicant should show no more than that there is evidence which, if accepted, will establish a cause of action.
The Adjudicator further noted that the Employer had taken steps to recover its alleged losses and had opened a criminal case. Since section 37D of the Act permits the withholding of benefits where an employer seeks to recover losses arising from fraud, dishonesty or misconduct, the withholding was found to be lawful.
The Adjudicator also found that the Complainant had been given an opportunity to make representations before the Fund reached its decision, meaning the process was procedurally fair.
The complaint was therefore dismissed, and the Adjudicator found that the Fund was entitled to continue withholding the withdrawal benefit pending the outcome of the legal proceedings.
This case confirms that a retirement fund may withhold a member’s benefit under section 37D where an employer has established a prima facie case of damages caused as a result of misrepresentation of credentials and is actively pursuing recovery of its losses. A final court judgment is not required before a fund may exercise its discretion to withhold the benefit.
Section 13A: Personal liability for unpaid contributions
Transport Sector Retirement Fund (Fund) v Clinx Medical Waste Management (Pty) Ltd (Employer) and Others[3]
The Fund lodged a complaint against the Employer for failing to pay retirement fund contributions and late payment interest in respect of its employees. The Fund alleged that contributions had not been paid for the period February 2024 to August 2025 and that the required contribution schedules had also not been submitted.
Neither the Employer nor the individuals identified as responsible persons filed a substantive response to the complaint.
The Fund sought to hold the Employer as well as certain individuals personally liable for the outstanding amounts. Three of the individuals were reflected in the CIPC records as directors of the Employer. A fourth individual had been identified by the Employer as a person responsible for the payment of contributions.
The Adjudicator confirmed that section 13A(8) is intended to hold accountable persons involved in the management of an employer’s financial affairs for non-compliance with the contribution requirements. In the case of a company, every director who is regularly involved in managing the company’s overall financial affairs may be personally liable for compliance with section 13A and payment of contributions.
However, the Adjudicator did not accept that the fourth individual was a responsible person for purposes of personal liability. The CIPC report did not reflect that individual as a director. The Adjudicator instead found that the Employer and the three directors reflected in the CIPC records could be held personally liable for the outstanding contributions and late payment interest.
There was nevertheless a problem with the amount claimed due to the employer not submitting the outstanding contribution schedules.
The Employer was ordered to submit the outstanding contribution schedules. If it failed to do so, the Fund was required to reconstruct them from the information already available to it and calculate the actual arrear contributions and late payment interest. The Employer and the three responsible directors were then ordered jointly and severally to pay the amounts calculated.
Section 13A liability does not necessarily stop with the employer. Directors who are regularly involved in managing a company’s overall financial affairs may also be exposed to personal liability for unpaid retirement fund contributions. Funds must, however, make sure that the persons they seek to hold personally liable properly fall within the requirements of section 13A. Funds must also be able to substantiate the amount claimed. Where contribution schedules are missing, an estimated amount may not be sufficient for an order sounding in money. The outstanding contributions must first be properly determined or reconstructed before payment can be ordered.
Constitutional Court Case
Exclusion of pension interests from redistribution orders in certain divorces unconstitutional
GD (Applicant) v Minister of Home Affairs and Others[4]
This case dealt with the constitutionality of section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act, which excluded pension interests from redistribution orders in respect of marriages concluded out of community of property and without the accrual system on or after 1 November 1984.
The Applicant and her husband were married out of community of property and without accrual in 2004. During divorce proceedings, the Applicant sought a redistribution order and challenged the constitutionality of section 7(7)(c), arguing that although the Constitutional Court had previously extended redistribution claims to spouses in post-1984 marriages, pension interests remained excluded from the assets that could be considered for redistribution.
The Applicant relied on expert evidence showing that women generally accumulate less retirement savings and pension wealth than men due to gender income disparities, interrupted careers, and the disproportionate burden of unpaid domestic and caregiving responsibilities. She argued that the exclusion of pension interests from redistribution disproportionately prejudiced women and perpetuated structural gender inequality.
The Constitutional Court agreed. It found that there was no longer any legitimate reason to differentiate between pre- and post-1984 marriages regarding the redistribution of pension interests. The Court held that section 7(7)(c) had become a provision that remained in the legislation even though the reason for it no longer existed.
It irrationally differentiated between spouses and unfairly discriminated against women, who are generally more likely to be disadvantaged by the exclusion of pension interests from redistribution orders.
The Court further accepted that unpaid domestic labour and caregiving responsibilities frequently enable spouses to advance their careers and accumulate retirement savings. Pension wealth therefore cannot be viewed in isolation from the indirect contributions made by spouses who devote time to maintaining households and raising families. These contributions may properly be considered by a court when determining a just and equitable redistribution of assets on divorce.
The Constitutional Court confirmed the High Court’s declaration of invalidity and held that section 7(7)(c) is unconstitutional because it irrationally differentiates between spouses and unfairly discriminates on the grounds of gender. The invalidity applies immediately but does not affect divorces that have already been finalised or matrimonial estates that have already been wound up and distributed.
This judgment significantly advances equality in divorce proceedings by confirming that pension interests may form part of the assets available for redistribution in marriages out of community of property and without accrual, irrespective of when the marriage was concluded.
It is important to keep in mind that although a party may be entitled to a portion of pension interest of the member spouse, the requirements of section 7(8) of the Divorce Act and section 37D of the Pension Funds Act still need to be complied with to enforce the order against the relevant fund. The requirements that must be met before a fund is bound to pay a non-member spouse directly are:
- The relevant fund must be named in or identifiable from the divorce order.
- It must be clear which percentage of the pension interest, or what amount is due or assigned to the non-member spouse.
- It must be specifically ordered that the fund should pay the amount concerned to the non-member spouse and make an endorsement to that effect in its records.
Financial Services Tribunal Cases
Clarifying the process for retirement fund withdrawals based on cessation of South African tax residency
BC du Plessis v The Pension Funds Adjudicator (Adjudicator), Discovery Investment Retirement Annuity Fund (Fund) and Discovery Life Investment Services (Pty) Ltd[5]
This matter concerned a member of a retirement annuity fund who sought access to his retirement annuity benefit before retirement on the basis that he had ceased to be a South African tax resident for an uninterrupted period exceeding three years. The member had lived abroad for many years and submitted various documents in support of his claim, including evidence of Dutch citizenship, a Dutch population register extract, a Netherlands address history, a Danish tax assessment and affidavits relating to his residence outside South Africa.
The Fund refused to process the withdrawal, maintaining that the member had not provided all the documents required to support an application for a SARS tax directive. These included proof of non-tax residency, a certificate of residence from the foreign tax authority, passport records reflecting departure from South Africa and proof relating to a blocked rand account. The Fund argued that without these documents it could not apply for a tax directive or pay the benefit. The Adjudicator agreed with the Fund and dismissed the complaint.
The member applied to the Financial Services Tribunal (Tribunal) for reconsideration. The Tribunal found that both the Fund and the Adjudicator had failed to properly engage with the legal meaning of “resident” as defined in the Income Tax Act. The Tribunal emphasised that the enquiry is not simply whether a member can produce certain documents. Instead, the Fund must consider the legal tests for tax residency, including ordinary residence, the physical presence test and the potential application of a double taxation agreement. The Tribunal noted that neither the Fund nor the Adjudicator had identified which test they were applying or determined the date on which the member allegedly ceased to be a South African tax resident.
The Tribunal further criticised the Fund for treating the matter as a documentary checklist exercise rather than evaluating the evidence presented by the member. Although the Tribunal found that the member had not yet established, on the available evidence, that he satisfied the requirements for withdrawal, it held that the Fund was obliged to properly consider all relevant evidence and explain any shortcomings. The Tribunal also found that affidavit evidence cannot simply be disregarded and that foreign documentation may be relevant when assessing tax residency.
Importantly, the Tribunal clarified the process that should be followed where a member seeks to withdraw a retirement annuity benefit on the basis of having ceased to be a South African tax resident. The Tribunal held that only the Fund or administrator may submit a tax directive application to SARS. Where a member has provided the information reasonably available to them and explained why further information cannot be furnished, the Fund should submit the application together with the available evidence and record any reservations it may have. SARS, and not the Fund, is ultimately responsible for determining whether the evidence is sufficient for purposes of issuing the tax directive.
The Tribunal set aside the Adjudicator’s determination and referred the complaint back to the Adjudicator for reconsideration.
This case confirms that retirement annuity withdrawal claims based on cessation of South African tax residency require more than a checklist approach. Funds must properly evaluate the legal tests for tax residency, consider all relevant evidence and provide clear reasons where evidence is found to be insufficient. The decision also clarifies that a fund should not prevent SARS from considering a matter by refusing to submit a tax directive application where a member has provided the information reasonably available to them. Ultimately, SARS remains the authority responsible for determining whether the requirements for a tax directive have been satisfied.
Death benefit calculations: Funds must be able to substantiate how a benefit was calculated
Lucia Maria Rodrigues Crawford v Eskom Pension and Provident Fund (Fund) and Pension Funds Adjudicator (Adjudicator)[6]
The deceased was a deferred pensioner of the Fund. Following his death, the Fund allocated 100% of his death benefit to his wife. The Fund initially calculated the death benefit at approximately R5.08 million but subsequently discovered that investment returns had incorrectly been added beyond the date of death and recalculated the benefit. Several different values were subsequently communicated, including approximately R4.836 million, R4.787 million and R4.783 million.
The deceased’s wife complained to the Adjudicator, disputing the calculation. The Adjudicator dismissed her complaint, accepting the Fund’s position that she was not entitled to the original overstated death benefit. She then applied to the Financial Services Tribunal (Tribunal) for reconsideration of that decision.
Importantly, before the Tribunal she accepted that she was not entitled to an amount that had been incorrectly overstated. Her concern was instead whether the Fund could properly substantiate the recalculated amount. She argued that several benefit statements were missing, different benefit amounts had been communicated, and she had not been provided with sufficient information to verify the Fund’s calculation.
The Fund acknowledged that benefit statements for 2013, 2016, 2019, 2021 and 2022 could not be retrieved. An Excel spreadsheet had been provided to the deceased’s wife, but it was not intended to reconstruct the missing statements and, it was not included in the record before the Tribunal.
The Tribunal found that there was doubt as to whether the benefit recalculations had been properly supported by complete, reliable and authentic evidence. The difficulty was compounded by the missing benefit statements and the fact that neither the Board nor the Adjudicator had all the relevant information before them when the calculations and complaint were considered.
The Tribunal emphasised that the real issue was therefore not whether the deceased’s wife was entitled to receive an incorrectly overstated benefit. Rather, the concern was the process followed in determining and substantiating the correct benefit. The deceased’s wife’s concerns regarding transparency, conflicting figures and incomplete records were justified.
The Tribunal accordingly upheld the reconsideration application, set aside the Adjudicator’s determination and referred the matter back to the Adjudicator to be considered afresh. No costs order was made.
Correcting an incorrectly calculated benefit is not, on its own, the problem. A fund must also be able to explain and substantiate how the corrected benefit was calculated. Where different benefit amounts are communicated, funds should ensure that the final calculation is supported by complete and reliable records and that the methodology used can be properly explained.
[1] PFA/NM/00131285/2025/SN
[2] PFA/MP/00134875/2025/TAM
[3] PFA/GP/00135288/2025/FN
[4] CCT 60/25) [2026] ZACC 39
[5] PFA30/2026
[6] PFA27/2026